Underlying Value

Underlying Value

High Conviction: The Deep Moat Compounder

Demonstrated operating prowess meets industry tailwinds to form a business likely to compound for a long time to come.

Andrew Pogue's avatar
Andrew Pogue
Mar 18, 2026
∙ Paid

Not investment advice: First, read my full disclaimer here.

Don’t tell me what you ‘like,’ tell me what you’re invested in…

Before any investment moves from a starter position (sub 1%) to a larger allocation, I make myself go through a checklist of sorts. This includes forming answers to the following questions:

  • Management: Are they strong operators? Allocators? Do I trust them?

  • Business: How well do I understand this business? What are the prospects for the industry? Is this a long-term investment or short-term trade? Do I have confidence in being able to predict performance? Over what time period?

  • Downside: How low is the floor?

  • Valuation: Is this an inexpensive valuation? How is that relative to global peers? Organic growth above/below the market and why? Who eats before me on the cap table and how does that impact downside?

  • Timing: What needs to go right for me to win? Mark this according to key milestones and check in periodically on the original thesis to make sure you’re not deluding yourself.

  • Why am I the lucky one?

Rarely do I feel strongly vindicated across the investment spectrum, 8/10 investments I’ll make have some known hair on them I get comfortable with (over time) for one reason or another.

To check these off in order, this is a:

  • Shareholder friendly management with demonstrated operational success.

  • A long-term investment that has significant tailwinds I think will continue for a long time. If this were a private opportunity, I would lock-up my investment over the next decade at current prices.

  • Net cash, capital light company that should be able to fund itself through internal cash generation.

  • A reasonable valuation much lower than larger (lower margin) peers. Organic growth that should see a double of the top/bottom line over the next 3-5 years.

  • Nothing spectacular needs to happen from the status quo despite a positive industry inflection. Book and execute 2-3 projects a year with at least one dropping down to a longer-term recurring operating stream.

  • Illiquid. Under-followed. Significant float is held by management. Sales cycle tends to lag the demonstrated forward momentum of the industry.

TLDR?

The company I am profiling today is one of my largest holdings. They have a world class service with limited competition, trade at an earnings yield over 10%, are net cash and have a management team I trust with significant skin in the game.

This is a high conviction, long-term position for me.

Management Check: I’ve spoken with the CEO and Chairman (2x).

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Substack Inc · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture